Coin Exchange NY Review

Disclaimer: We are reader supported.  We may be compensated from the links in this post, if you use products or services based on our expert recommendations. Please read our Advertising Disclosure.

Coin Exchange NY operates out of a storefront at 3 S. Central Ave in Hartsdale, New York, in the heart of Westchester County.

The business buys and sells gold, silver, platinum, palladium, rare coins, paper currency, estate jewelry, and pre-owned watches from brands like Rolex, Cartier, and David Yurman.

It has been around since roughly 1994, which puts it past three decades in a business where a lot of local shops open and close within five years.

This review looks at what the company actually offers, what customers say about the experience, and how its pricing model stacks up against the current precious metals market.

Key Takeaways

• Coin Exchange NY is a Hartsdale-based dealer that buys and sells bullion, coins, currency, and jewelry, with prices tied to live spot rates for gold, silver, platinum, and palladium.
• Customer reviews across Yelp and Google consistently mention fair pricing and knowledgeable staff, with almost no complaints filed against the business through the Better Business Bureau.
• Gold traded above $4,100 per ounce in early July 2026, up roughly $835 from a year earlier, which directly affects what the shop pays for scrap gold and bullion right now.

What the Company Actually Does

Walk into the Hartsdale location and you're looking at three separate businesses stitched together.

There's the bullion side: gold and silver coins, bars, and rounds from mints like the U.S. Mint, Royal Canadian Mint, Perth Mint, and PAMP Suisse.

 There's the numismatic side: pre-1933 gold, Morgan and Peace dollars, civil war tokens, and old U.S. currency, the kind of inventory that draws in serious collectors rather than casual buyers. 

And there's the jewelry and watch side, where they'll appraise and buy estate pieces, scrap gold, and luxury watches.

Most local coin shops pick one lane. Coin Exchange NY runs all three at once, which is either a strength or a distraction depending on what you walked in for.

If you're selling your grandmother's silverware and a box of old coins in the same visit, having one shop handle both saves a trip.

If you're a serious numismatist looking for deep specialized inventory in one narrow category, a shop that only does coins might have more depth in that specific area.

Services Snapshot

No appointment is required for a walk-in appraisal, and the company states there's no charge to have an item evaluated. That matters because some competitors charge a flat appraisal fee whether or not you end up selling.

Pricing Model: How Spot Pricing Actually Works Here

The numismatic side of the business deserves its own mention because it's easy to overlook next to the bullion pricing.

Coin Exchange NY carries pre-1933 U.S. gold, including double eagles, liberty eagles, and early gold issues, along with type coins spanning half cents through silver dollars, three-cent nickels, twenty-cent pieces, and civil war tokens. 

These are collector categories where price is driven by rarity, grade, and demand rather than metal weight alone, and they require a different kind of expertise than simply weighing scrap gold.

This matters for anyone inheriting a coin collection without knowing what's in it. A box of old coins might contain common-date pieces worth only bullion value alongside a scarcer date worth many times that.

A shop that buys strictly by weight will miss that distinction, or worse, offer melt value on something with real collector premium. 

One review describing a months-long process of cataloging and selling a family collection suggests the numismatic side gets used for exactly this kind of situation.

How It Compares Locally

Westchester County has a handful of competing coin and gold buyers, including Northeastern Metals Corp and Tarrytown Jewelers, both within a short drive of Hartsdale.

Tarrytown Jewelers has held BBB accreditation since 1991 and has been in business since 1978, giving it a longer accredited track record on paper.

Coin Exchange NY's advantage isn't tenure with the BBB. It's the combination of bullion, numismatics, and jewelry under one roof, plus an active online store that extends its reach past Westchester through eBay listings and its own e-commerce site.

For someone deciding where to sell, three questions matter more than brand reputation alone:

Coin Exchange NY checks all three boxes based on its stated policies and the reviews describing actual visits.

A Few Practical Notes

The store is open six days a week according to listed hours, closed or on limited hours Sunday, and located near the intersection of S Central Ave and Hartsdale Ave, easy enough to find without GPS once you're in the area.

It accepts credit cards, which not every cash-focused coin shop does. And it maintains an active social media presence across Facebook, Instagram, and X, along with live chat on its website for quick questions before you make the trip.

If there's a gap, it's transparency around specific buy-back percentages. Like most dealers, Coin Exchange NY doesn't publish exactly what percentage of spot it pays for scrap gold versus bullion coins versus rare numismatics, because that number shifts by item and by day.

That's standard industry practice, not a red flag specific to this shop, but it does mean the burden is on you to ask directly and maybe get a second quote elsewhere before finalizing a bigger sale.