California Gold & Silver Exchange Review

Disclaimer: We are reader supported.  We may be compensated from the links in this post, if you use products or services based on our expert recommendations. Please read our Advertising Disclosure.

California Gold & Silver Exchange (CGSE) is a family-owned precious metals dealer in Upland, California, buying and selling gold, silver, platinum, diamonds, coins, and bullion out of a single storefront on Mountain Avenue.

The business has operated since 2011 under owners Michael and Maria Brewart, whose family background in the Southern California gold trade goes back more than 40 years.

This review looks at what CGSE actually offers, how its process works, what customers say about it, and how it stacks up against other options if you're sitting on jewelry, coins, or scrap metal and wondering what it's worth.

Key Takeaways

• CGSE is a walk-in-only, Upland-based dealer that pays cash or check on the spot after weighing and testing items in front of the customer.
• The company holds an A+ BBB rating and a 4.6 to 5-star average across Yelp and Birdeye, based on more than 100 combined reviews.
• Gold traded near $4,010 to $4,028 per ounce and silver near $57 per ounce in July 2026, both up sharply year over year, which affects payout timing and refinery turnaround.

What CGSE Buys and Sells

CGSE operates on both sides of the counter. On the buying side, the company purchases gold and silver jewelry, sterling flatware and tea sets, dental gold, diamonds, platinum, gold and silver coins, PCGS and NGC graded coins, and bullion bars and rounds.

On the selling side, it stocks gold and silver coins and bars, along with platinum, for customers looking to buy rather than liquidate. This two-way structure is common among regional exchanges but not universal.

Many pawn shops and jewelry stores buy but don't maintain a sell-side inventory, and many bullion-only dealers sell but won't touch scrap jewelry or dental gold.

Here's a quick breakdown of the category coverage:

One detail worth flagging up front: CGSE does not accept mail-in or shipped items. Everything happens in person at the Upland store.

If you're not within reasonable driving distance of the Inland Empire, this isn't going to be a workable option, and you'd be better off looking at a mail-in refiner instead.

How the Process Works

The process CGSE describes is straightforward and matches what reviewers report experiencing:

1. Bring your items (jewelry, coins, diamonds, silverware, dental gold, whatever applies) to the Upland location.
2. Staff test and weigh everything in front of you using a Thermo Scientific XRF precious metals analyzer, which reads the exact karat of gold rather than relying on an acid test alone.
3. You receive a cash or check offer on the spot, with no obligation to accept it.

The XRF analyzer is a meaningful detail for anyone who's dealt with a shop that eyeballs karat or relies solely on acid testing, which can be less precise on mixed alloys or plated items.

CGSE also notes it pays extra attention to higher-karat gold (18k, 21k, 22k, 24k), which matters if you've got jewelry purchased overseas, since much of Europe, the Middle East, India, and parts of Asia sell gold in higher karats than the 10k-14k standard common in the US.

Reputation and Reviews

This is where things get more interesting, and where a prospective seller should actually spend time before driving out to Upland.

CGSE carries an A+ rating from the Better Business Bureau and has been BBB accredited since 2014. On Yelp, the business shows roughly 199 reviews with a strong average, and a separate aggregator, Birdeye, lists 141 reviews at a 4.6-star average. Recurring themes in customer feedback include:

That said, no dealer is complaint-free. The BBB profile shows at least one filed complaint despite the strong overall rating, and as with any single-location cash-for-gold business,

your experience can vary depending on which staff member handles your visit and what specific items you bring in.

A five-star average built on 100-plus reviews is a genuinely strong signal for a business this size, but it's not a guarantee of a specific price on a specific day.

Market Conditions Right Now

Precious metals pricing context matters more than usual heading into late 2026. Gold has been trading in the $4,000 to $4,100 per ounce range through mid-to-late July 2026, sitting roughly 17-18% higher than the same point last year.

Silver has been more volatile on a percentage basis, trading near $57 per ounce in late July, up more than $18 an ounce compared to a year earlier.

That run-up has created a side effect worth knowing about before you sell: refinery backlogs.

With gold pushing past historic milestones and silver seeing similarly sharp gains, some dealers and refineries have reported longer processing times and even temporary pauses on accepting new scrap volume.

This doesn't necessarily change what a local dealer like CGSE pays a walk-in customer on the spot, since that payout is negotiated at the counter rather than tied directly to refinery turnaround.

But it's a useful piece of context for understanding why the broader gold-buying industry has looked a little different in 2026 than in prior years, and why comparing quotes across two or three shops before committing is still worth the extra hour.

A rough way to sanity-check any offer: multiply the current spot price per ounce by the weight of your item in troy ounces, then by the purity percentage (for example, 14k gold is about 58.3% pure).

That gives you the melt value. Dealers pay a percentage below melt value to cover testing, refining, and margin, and that percentage is really what you're comparing between shops, not the flat dollar number on the offer sheet.

Silver's price swing is worth an extra sentence on its own, because it's been the more dramatic story of 2026. A year ago silver was trading well under $40 an ounce.

At close to $57 now, that's a gain most sellers of old flatware, coin collections, or junk silver bags haven't seen reflected in their expectations yet, since a lot of people still price silver in their heads based on where it sat a few years back.

If you've got sterling silver sitting in a drawer, this is a materially better year to have it appraised than 2023 or 2024 was.

Where CGSE Fits Compared to Alternatives

If you're weighing CGSE against other options, here's roughly how the landscape breaks down:

For someone in the Inland Empire or greater LA area with jewelry, scrap gold, dental gold, or coins to sell, CGSE's combination of in-person testing, a long operating history, and a strong review base makes it a reasonable first or second stop.

It's worth getting one comparison quote regardless of which dealer you choose first, simply because payout percentages against melt value can vary by several points between shops.