Disclaimer: We are reader supported. We may be compensated from the links in this post, if you use products or services based on our expert recommendations. Please read our Advertising Disclosure.
Coins Online is the e-commerce storefront for American Rare Coin & Collectibles, a Bloomington, Minnesota dealer that has operated out of the same Twin Cities location since the late 1980s.
The site sells gold, silver, platinum, and palladium coins and bars from mints like the U.S. Mint, Royal Canadian Mint, and Perth Mint, alongside rare and collectible coins.
This review looks at what the company sells, how its pricing stacks up against current spot prices, and what buyers and sellers can expect from the transaction process.
Key Takeaways
- Coins Online is operated by American Rare Coin & Collectibles, a Minnesota dealer founded in 1989 with an A+ Better Business Bureau rating.
- Product premiums over spot price ranged from roughly 4% to 14% on gold and silver items checked in late July 2026, which is in line with typical bullion dealer markups.
- The company buys as well as sells, offers a self-directed precious metals IRA program, and holds authorized dealer status with PCGS.
Before we get started with this review:
We understand how difficult it is to pick a company that you can trust with your hard earned savings. That's why we create informative and useful information to give you as much knowledge as possible to make the right decision.
We created a list of our highest recommended investment companies, to make comparing and choosing the company best suited to your needs as easy as possible.
Look to see the Coins Online was selected to our "highest recommendation" list this year!
Or...
Get a FREE Gold Investing Packet from our #1 recommendation:
Protect Your Wealth & Get Huge Tax Savings!
Who Runs Coins Online
American Rare Coin & Collectibles has worked out of 7900 Xerxes Ave. S in Bloomington since 1989.
Coins Online is the company's online sales channel, built to serve customers outside the Twin Cities metro who want to buy or sell without visiting the physical shop.
The company states it has more than 200 years of combined numismatic experience on staff and has served over 100,000 customers.
Those figures come from the company itself, not an independent audit, so treat them as claims rather than verified counts.
What can be verified independently is the business address, the BBB accreditation, and the PCGS dealer listing, all of which line up with a real, long-running brick-and-mortar coin shop rather than a drop-ship operation with a generic web storefront.
What Coins Online Sells
The catalog splits into four metal categories, plus a "More" section for collectible and circulated coins.
Best-selling items on the site skew toward small, liquid silver products. A 2026 American Silver Eagle 1 oz BU coin was priced at $66.17 at the time of this review, and a random-year Silver Eagle was listed at $65.84.
On the gold side, a 1 oz Credit Suisse gold bar ran $4,239.07, and a 1 oz Argor-Heraeus KineBar sold for $4,207.13.
Protect Your Wealth & Get Huge Tax Savings!
How Coins Online Prices Compare to Spot
Spot gold traded around $4,029 per ounce on July 29, 2026, according to Trading Economics, and spot silver was near $58.05 per ounce the same day.
Comparing those numbers against listed retail prices gives a useful read on markup, since premium size is one of the clearest indicators of value for a bullion buyer.
| Product | Listed Price | Spot Value | Premium | Premium % |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2026 Silver Eagle 1 oz BU | $66.17 | $58.05 | $8.12 | 14.0% |
| Silver Eagle 1 oz (random year) | $65.84 | $58.05 | $7.79 | 13.4% |
| Silver Round 1 oz (varied design) | $62.46 | $58.05 | $4.41 | 7.6% |
| 1 oz Credit Suisse Gold Bar | $4,239.07 | $4,029.08 | $209.99 | 5.2% |
| 1 oz Argor-Heraeus Gold Bar | $4,207.13 | $4,029.08 | $178.05 | 4.4% |
| 10 oz Credit Suisse Gold Bar | $42,493.68 | $40,290.80 | $2,202.88 | 5.5% |
Gold premiums here sit in a fairly normal range for U.S. dealers, generally 3% to 6% over spot on one-ounce bars from major refiners. Silver premiums run higher in percentage terms, which is typical of the category.
Coins carry more manufacturing cost per ounce than bars, and government-minted coins like the Silver Eagle carry an extra premium for the guarantee behind them.
A 14% premium on a Silver Eagle isn't unusual industry-wide, but buyers who only care about ounces in the vault rather than coin design can often do better with generic rounds, which is exactly what the 7.6% premium on the varied-design round shows.
The 2026 Precious Metals Market
Gold has moved a lot this year. Spot gold sat near $4,020 to $4,100 an ounce through most of late July 2026, up about 24% from the same point last year, per Trading Economics data.
The World Gold Council recorded 53 new all-time highs for gold in 2025 alone, and annual demand topped 5,000 metric tons for the first time on record.
Silver moved even more sharply. It traded near $58 an ounce on July 29, 2026, up somewhere between 50% and 60% year over year depending on the measurement window, and JM Bullion described current levels as near decade highs.
For a buyer, that context matters. Dealer premiums stay relatively stable in dollar terms even as spot prices swing, so a rising spot price actually shrinks the percentage premium on a given coin over time.
It also means the entry price for a full ounce of gold has gotten a lot steeper for smaller investors, which is one reason fractional coins and bars get more attention in markets like this one.
Trust Signals and Accreditations
American Rare Coin & Collectibles is a PCGS authorized dealer, listed under contact Matthew Abbott at the Bloomington address.
The BBB profile for the company shows an A+ rating, with accreditation dating to March 2022. Third-party review aggregation puts the company around 4.7 out of 5 on Angi and roughly 4.3 out of 5 on Google, based on a mix of buying and selling transactions.
The homepage also displays NGC, ANA, PNG, and Yelp badges, which is standard practice among established coin dealers but worth verifying independently rather than taking at face value.
Checking a dealer's BBB file directly, rather than trusting a badge image on a website, remains the more reliable step.
Selling to Coins Online
The company runs a buyback side of the business under the "Sell" tab, marketed with the tagline "Sell Your Precious Metals with Trust and Ease."
Selling coins, bullion, currency, or gold jewelry to a dealer with a physical location and decades of operating history carries less counterparty risk than mailing items to an unknown online-only buyer.
That said, no buyback offer should be accepted without comparing it against at least one competing quote, since dealer buy prices vary and negotiating room exists even at reputable shops.
Precious Metals IRA Program
Coins Online offers a self-directed IRA program for holding physical gold, silver, platinum, and palladium inside a retirement account.
This structure requires an IRS-approved custodian and depository, standard for any precious metals IRA regardless of which dealer sets it up.
Anyone considering this route should confirm storage fees, custodian fees, and buyback terms in writing before funding an account.
These programs can make sense for portfolio diversification, but the fee stack (setup, annual custodian, and storage) tends to run higher than a standard brokerage IRA, so the math only works for some investors.
Customer Feedback
Reviews posted on the Coins Online homepage describe positive experiences with both buying and selling, including praise for a staff member named Rick handling an estate coin sale.
Homepage testimonials are self-selected by the business, so they should be read as supporting evidence rather than the full picture.
Independent platforms like Yelp and the BBB give a more complete view, and both show a pattern of largely positive feedback with occasional complaints tied to buyback offer amounts, which is common across the coin dealing industry generally.
Protect Your Wealth & Get Huge Tax Savings!
FAQ
Is Coins Online a legitimate dealer?
Yes. It operates as the online arm of American Rare Coin & Collectibles, a Minnesota business founded in 1989 with an A+ BBB rating and PCGS authorized dealer status.
Are Coins Online's prices competitive?
Premiums checked in July 2026 ranged from about 4% to 14% over spot, depending on the product. That range is typical for U.S. bullion dealers, though generic rounds and bars tend to offer lower premiums than branded coins.
Does Coins Online buy coins as well as sell them?
Yes, through its Sell page and the physical Bloomington location.
Does the company offer a gold IRA?
Yes, a self-directed precious metals IRA program is listed under Services.
The Verdict
Coins Online is a real, long-running dealer with verifiable accreditation and pricing that falls within normal industry ranges.
Buyers should still compare premiums across a few dealers before purchasing, particularly on coin products where the markup runs highest.