Disclaimer: We are reader supported. We may be compensated from the links in this post, if you use products or services based on our expert recommendations. Please read our Advertising Disclosure.
AmFed Coin & Bullion, formally known as American Federal Rare Coin and Bullion, is a precious metals and rare coin dealer based in Carefree, Arizona.
Founded in 1983, the company has built a client base of more than 40,000 customers over four decades, operating from a single brick-and-mortar location at 500 Easy Street while also serving buyers and sellers nationwide through phone and its online shop at americanfederal.com.
With gold surging 65% in 2025 and silver climbing more than 150% over the same period, the timing of this review matters: investors entering or expanding their positions in physical metals today are doing so in a radically different market than just two years ago, and the dealer they choose carries real financial weight.
Key Takeaways
- AmFed has operated since 1983, serves 40,000+ clients, and focuses on certified rare coins and physical bullion across gold, silver, platinum, and palladium.
- The company does not publish live pricing online; buyers must call for quotes, which suits relationship-based investors but can frustrate comparison shoppers.
- Customer reviews across Trustpilot and Yelp are consistently strong, with repeat buyers citing transparent fees, no-pressure sales, and knowledgeable staff as the main reasons they return.
Before we get started with this review:
We understand how difficult it is to pick a company that you can trust with your hard earned savings. That's why we create informative and useful information to give you as much knowledge as possible to make the right decision.
We created a list of our highest recommended investment companies, to make comparing and choosing the company best suited to your needs as easy as possible.
Look to see if the AmFed Coin & Bullion was selected to our "highest recommendation" list this year!
Or...
Get a FREE Gold Investing Packet from our #1 recommendation:
Protect Your Wealth & Get Huge Tax Savings!
Company Background
Nick Grovich has served as president and owner since 1985, one year after the company transitioned from its early wholesale roots. Don Gause, vice president and expert numismatist, has been with the firm since 1986 and handles much of the client education and coin pricing work.
The two have led the operation through multiple precious metals cycles, including the 1980 silver spike, the post-2008 gold run, and the record-breaking rally of 2025.
AmFed is a member of the American Numismatic Association, the Industry Council for Tangible Assets, and the Texas Numismatic Association, among other industry bodies.
The company was also among the earliest dealers to participate in NGC (Numismatic Guaranty Company) coin grading services from their inception. That's a meaningful credential in the rare coin market, where authenticity and grading directly determine value.
Dennis Prager, the nationally syndicated radio host, has been a publicly stated advocate for AmFed for over seven years and frequently mentions the company on air.
The relationship has brought in a consistent stream of new clients, many of whom note the Prager endorsement as their initial reason for making contact.
What the Market Looks Like Right Now
Anyone shopping for physical metals in 2025 or 2026 is navigating a genuinely volatile environment. Gold closed 2025 up 65.2% for the year, crossing $4,300 per ounce after setting more than 50 new all-time highs throughout the year.
Silver outperformed it dramatically, closing up 150.1% over the same period after climbing above $80 per ounce for the first time on record. Platinum and palladium also posted strong gains, though both lag the explosive moves in gold and silver.
The drivers behind this rally are structural, not speculative noise. Central banks globally increased gold reserves steadily from 2022 through 2025, motivated by a desire to reduce dependence on U.S. dollar reserves. According to J.P. Morgan, gold overtook U.S.
Treasuries as the largest share of global reserves for the first time in 30 years during this period. A 2025 survey cited by J.P. Morgan found that 95% of central banks expect global gold reserves to rise further in 2026.
Silver's move has been amplified by industrial demand, particularly from solar photovoltaic manufacturing, which accounted for nearly 29% of total silver industrial demand in 2024 according to BlackRock, up from just 11% in 2014.
What this means practically: buyers today are paying historically high premiums over spot, and the choice of dealer, the products they carry, and how they price their inventory has never mattered more per transaction.
Protect Your Wealth & Get Huge Tax Savings!
Products and Services
AmFed operates across four main areas: buying, selling, appraisal, and consignment of rare coins and bullion. The product lineup covers all four major precious metals.
Bullion Products
| Metal | Representative Products |
|---|---|
| Gold | American Gold Eagle, Austrian Gold Philharmonic, Gold Australian Kangaroo |
| Silver | American Silver Eagle, Silver Panda, British Silver Britannia, silver bars |
| Platinum | American Platinum Eagle, Canadian Platinum Maple Leaf, 10-oz Platinum Bar |
| Palladium | Palladium bullion coins and bars |
Rare and Collectible Coins
The company's primary area of expertise is certified, high-quality, and rare-date coins.
AmFed deals in semi-numismatic coins, U.S. classic gold coins, world coins spanning Asia, Europe, the Middle East, Africa, and South America, and obsolete U.S. currencies including gold certificates, large-size notes, silver certificates, Confederate currencies, and fractional currencies.
The inventory skews toward quality over volume, which is consistent with the NGC relationship and the firm's wholesale origins.
Free Portfolio Review
One service that stands out relative to many competitors is the free coin performance review. Clients can bring or send their existing holdings for evaluation, and the staff will assess whether current positions are appropriately priced and well-suited to the client's goals.
Multiple customer testimonials reference specific instances where this review caught pricing errors or identified underperforming holdings, including one client who states they ended up $122,500 ahead after AmFed helped them restructure a prior dealer's recommendations.
Precious Metals IRA
AmFed addresses precious metals IRAs on its website and provides general educational content on how they work.
The details around specific custodian partnerships are not clearly disclosed online, so buyers interested in IRA-eligible products should call directly to get specifics before assuming the service is fully operational from end to end.
Pricing Transparency
AmFed does not list live prices on its website. All pricing is handled over the phone after account creation, which is a model more common among relationship-focused dealers than high-volume online retailers.
For some buyers, particularly those making large or complex purchases, this works well: the staff can tailor recommendations based on individual portfolio goals, risk tolerance, and current market conditions. For buyers used to comparison shopping across multiple tabs, it adds friction.
On the fee transparency question, customer reviews are notably specific. Multiple Trustpilot reviewers with accounts spanning several years describe AmFed as "completely transparent" with their fees and consistently competitive in buy-sell spreads.
One long-term customer who has done several hundred thousand dollars in business with the firm specifically cites the transparency as a reason for continued loyalty.
Buying and Selling Process
There are three ways to transact with AmFed:
- Online: The website at americanfederal.com hosts a shop, though pricing requires account creation and often a phone call.
- Phone: Call 1-800-221-7694 to get a quote, place an order, or discuss a sale. The toll-free line is the primary channel for most clients.
- In person: The Carefree, Arizona location is open Monday through Friday, 8:00 AM to 5:00 PM. It is closed on weekends.
AmFed accepts all major credit cards. For sellers, the company buys coins and bullion regardless of where the original purchase was made, and advertises fast payment upon completion.
Customer Experience
As of early 2026, AmFed has 697 reviews on Trustpilot, the vast majority of which are positive. Specific staff members come up repeatedly by name: Carl, Michelle, JP Blanchard, Don Gause, and Nick Grovich himself.
This pattern of name-specific praise is a reliable signal that the sales team is small, consistent, and personally accountable. Large-volume dealers with high turnover rarely produce reviews where customers form enough of a relationship to name the staff member unprompted.
Common themes across the reviews include:
Negative reviews are rare but do exist. A small number mention delivery delays tied to postal service issues rather than AmFed directly, and at least one reviewer noted that the company's slower, relationship-based model is not suited to fast-turnaround speculative buyers looking to capitalize on intraday price moves.
Protect Your Wealth & Get Huge Tax Savings!
Who AmFed Is Best For
AmFed's model is built for a specific type of buyer.
It suits investors who want a dealer relationship over a transactional one, collectors focused on certified rare coins, buyers who prefer phone-based guidance over self-directed online purchases, and clients making larger, less frequent purchases where the absence of live pricing matters less than access to expert advice.
It is less suited for buyers who want full online price transparency, those placing small frequent orders at tight spreads, or investors who specifically need a fully integrated IRA administration service without additional research calls.
What Sets AmFed Apart
Four decades of operation through multiple market cycles is a concrete differentiator. Many precious metals dealers that emerged during the 2008 to 2012 gold bull market have since closed, consolidated, or shifted business models.
AmFed's longevity since 1983 means the team has seen the 1980 commodity spike, the doldrums of the 1990s, the post-9/11 metals run, the 2008 financial crisis surge, and the 2025 record-breaking rally.
That accumulated perspective informs advice in ways that a newer dealer simply cannot replicate.
The early involvement with NGC grading is also worth noting. Graded coins carry a certified authenticity and grade that protects buyers from misrepresentation and, in the collectibles market, often commands a price premium.
A dealer who participated in that system from the start has a fundamentally different orientation toward product quality than one who simply sources whatever moves fastest.
Conclusion
AmFed Coin & Bullion is a well-established, relationship-first dealer with a strong track record, verifiable customer satisfaction across hundreds of independent reviews, and genuine expertise in both rare coins and physical bullion across all four major metals.
Buyers who call for a quote rather than click to buy will find a team that is consistently described as knowledgeable, transparent, and non-pushy in a market where those qualities are far from universal.